Overview
There is a particular kind of cigar that does not shout for attention but instead rewards the smoker who leans in. The Excalibur by Hoyo de Monterrey No. I is that cigar. Introduced in the 1970s as a premium sub-brand under the Hoyo de Monterrey umbrella, it was blended during the golden era of Honduran cigar-making under Frank Llaneza, and it carries that pedigree with quiet confidence. In a market increasingly dominated by power-blends and pepper bombs, the Excalibur No. I remains a thinking person's smoke — a Churchill that asks for patience and returns it with layers of old-world complexity. The cold draw sets the tone: dry cedar and a whisper of floral sweetness, like the first breath of a cedar-lined humidor. Once lit, the first third unfolds with creamy toasted nuts — cashew and almond — layered over mild leather and a white pepper retrohale that tingles without stinging. The draw is generous, producing a pillowy, cool smoke that eases the palate into the experience rather than jolting it awake.
As the burn progresses into the second third, the cigar deepens considerably. The cedar transitions toward aged oak, and a rich earth note emerges alongside light cocoa powder. A subtle caramel sweetness threads through the smoke, balancing a growing but never aggressive spice presence. This is where the Excalibur No. I reveals its true character: nuanced rather than bold, complex rather than loud. The smoke remains cool and dense, and the flavors shift with each puff — now oak, now cocoa, now a hint of caramel — never settling into a single note but always harmonious. It is a blend that rewards attention; smoke it too quickly and you miss the conversation.
The final third brings a warming increase in strength without turning sharp. Dark roasted coffee grounds, dried leather, and a dried-fruit sweetness — raisin or dark fig — round out the experience. The finish is medium-long with a pleasant woody bitterness and lingering cocoa on the palate. Construction is consistently excellent, a hallmark of the General Cigar Honduran factory: the burn is even, the draw slightly firm, the ash holds in inch-plus columns, and the burn line rarely requires touch-ups. This is a cigar that demands time — a 90- to 100-minute smoke suited for a relaxed afternoon or early evening session, ideally on a porch or patio where the full arc can be appreciated without distraction.
What makes the Excalibur No. I distinctive is not any single flavor but the way it balances restraint and richness. It captures a restrained, old-world complexity that many modern power-blend enthusiasts overlook. For the seasoned palate who appreciates subtlety over shock, this is a benchmark smoke — and at $12–$18 per cigar, it represents one of the most underrated value propositions in classic premium cigars. If you came of age in the hobby during the 1990s boom, the Excalibur No. I is both a nostalgia trip and a reminder of what Honduran tobacco can do when blended with patience and precision.
Cigar Specifications
| Wrapper | Honduran Shade-Grown Natural — Colorado |
|---|---|
| Binder | Honduran |
| Filler | Honduran and Nicaraguan long-fillers, aged tobaccos blended at the Villazon/General Cigar factory in Honduras |
| Country of Origin | Danlí, Honduras |
| Vitola / Shape | Churchill |
| Size | 7.0 x 54 |
| Strength | Medium |
| Price | $12–$18 per cigar |
| Tier | Premium |
| Aging | Tobaccos aged a minimum of three years prior to rolling; box aging recommended for 6–12 months to further integrate the |
Tasting Notes & Flavor Progression
First Third
The cold draw opens with dry cedar and a whisper of floral sweetness. Once lit, the first third delivers creamy toasted nuts — cashew and almond — layered over mild leather and white pepper on the retrohale. The draw is generous, producing a pillowy, cool smoke that eases the palate into the experience.
Second Third
The core flavors deepen considerably — cedar transitions toward aged oak, and a rich earth note emerges alongside light cocoa powder. A subtle caramel sweetness threads through the smoke, balancing a growing but never aggressive spice presence. Complexity is the hallmark here; the smoke is nuanced rather than bold.
Final Third
The final third brings a warming increase in strength without turning sharp. Dark roasted coffee grounds, dried leather, and a dried-fruit sweetness — raisin or dark fig — round out the experience. The finish is medium-long with a pleasant woody bitterness and lingering cocoa on the palate.
Construction, Burn & Draw
Construction is consistently excellent — a hallmark of the General Cigar Honduran factory. Burns with an even, slightly firm draw that produces dense, cool smoke; ash holds firm in inch-plus columns and the burn line rarely requires touch-ups.
Pairing Recommendations
Spirit
Single malt Scotch from the Highlands — Dalmore 12 or Glenmorangie Original complement the cedar and caramel notes beautifully; alternatively, a well-aged añejo rum such as Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva mirrors the sweetness in the blend
Wine
A medium-bodied Tempranillo — Rioja Reserva such as Muga or La Rioja Alta Gran Reserva 904 — whose dried fruit and leather notes echo the cigar's second and final thirds without overpowering it
Non-Alcoholic
A single-origin Colombian medium roast, slightly cooled to lukewarm — the nutty, mild-chocolate profile amplifies the cocoa and almond notes in the smoke without introducing competing bitterness
Who Should Smoke This?
Picture a seasoned smoker on a quiet Saturday afternoon, perhaps on a screened porch with a book he may or may not actually read. He has been in the hobby for years, maybe decades, and he has grown tired of cigars that try too hard — the triple-ligero pepper bombs, the flavor-of-the-month releases. He wants something that feels like an old friend: familiar, unhurried, and quietly rewarding. He already enjoys medium-bodied Honduran blends, perhaps a classic Punch or a vintage Hoyo, and he appreciates a cigar that evolves slowly rather than hitting him over the head. The Excalibur No. I gives him that. It asks for 90 minutes of his time and returns it with a nuanced arc — creamy nuts to aged oak to dark coffee and dried fig — that unfolds only if he pays attention. This is not a cigar for the distracted or the impatient. It is for the smoker who understands that the best conversations are the ones that take their time.
Bottom Line
The Excalibur by Hoyo de Monterrey No. I is a masterclass in restrained, old-world complexity — a Churchill that rewards patience with a nuanced, 90-minute journey from creamy nuts to dark coffee and dried fruit. At $12–$18, it is one of the most underrated values in premium cigars. If you appreciate subtlety over shock, this is a cigar you should be smoking.
Similar Cigars
Explore all Hoyo de Monterrey cigars.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Excalibur by Hoyo de Monterrey No. I a strong cigar?
No. It is rated Medium (3/5) in strength. Physically, that means you will feel a gentle warmth in the final third but no nicotine rush or lightheadedness. It is a cigar you can smoke on an empty stomach without concern, though the 90-minute duration means you may want a glass of water nearby.
What does Excalibur by Hoyo de Monterrey No. I taste like?
The first third delivers creamy toasted nuts — cashew and almond — over mild leather and white pepper on the retrohale. The second third deepens into aged oak, rich earth, light cocoa powder, and a subtle caramel sweetness. The final third brings dark roasted coffee grounds, dried leather, and a dried-fruit sweetness like raisin or dark fig, with a medium-long finish of woody bitterness and lingering cocoa.
How long does Excalibur by Hoyo de Monterrey No. I take to smoke?
Expect 90 to 100 minutes. The Churchill vitola (7.0 x 54) is a large format that demands time and attention. Smoking it too quickly will cause the flavors to turn harsh, so pace yourself and enjoy the full arc.
What is the best pairing for Excalibur by Hoyo de Monterrey No. I?
A single malt Scotch from the Highlands, such as Dalmore 12 or Glenmorangie Original, complements the cedar and caramel notes beautifully. Alternatively, a well-aged añejo rum like Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva mirrors the sweetness in the blend. For wine, a medium-bodied Tempranillo — Rioja Reserva such as Muga or La Rioja Alta Gran Reserva 904 — echoes the dried fruit and leather notes without overpowering. For a non-alcoholic option, a single-origin Colombian medium roast, slightly cooled to lukewarm, amplifies the cocoa and almond notes without introducing competing bitterness.
Is Excalibur by Hoyo de Monterrey No. I good for beginners?
It is not ideal for a complete beginner. While the Medium strength is approachable, the Churchill format requires 90–100 minutes of focused attention, and the nuanced flavors — aged oak, dried fig, subtle caramel — are best appreciated by a palate that has already developed a reference for Honduran tobacco. At $12–$18 per cigar, it is also a bit pricey for a first-timer who may not yet discern its subtleties. Beginners should start with a smaller, milder cigar before graduating to this one.
Where can I buy Excalibur by Hoyo de Monterrey No. I?
This cigar is sold at premium tobacconists, online cigar retailers, and some well-stocked liquor stores with humidors. Because it is a classic, non-limited release, it is widely available. Look for retailers that specialize in Honduran cigars or carry the General Cigar portfolio. Buying from a reputable source ensures proper storage and authenticity.
What is the price of Excalibur by Hoyo de Monterrey No. I?
The Excalibur by Hoyo de Monterrey No. I typically retails for $12–$18 per cigar, depending on the retailer and taxes. At that price, it sits in the premium tier but remains one of the better values in classic Honduran cigars, especially given the three-year minimum aging of its tobaccos.
Is Excalibur by Hoyo de Monterrey No. I worth aging?
Yes. The tobaccos are already aged a minimum of three years prior to rolling, so the cigar is ready to smoke upon purchase. However, box aging for 6–12 months will further integrate the blend, softening the white pepper on the retrohale and deepening the caramel and dried-fruit notes. The Honduran Shade-Grown Natural wrapper, being a medium-brown Colorado leaf, will continue to marry with the filler over time. If you have the patience, a year in the humidor rewards you with a more cohesive, rounded smoke.
What wrapper does Excalibur by Hoyo de Monterrey No. I use?
It uses a Honduran Shade-Grown Natural wrapper. This leaf is a Colorado shade — medium brown, silky with a subtle satin sheen, and minimal tooth. That wrapper contributes a gentle cedar and leather character to the blend, along with a faint floral sweetness on the cold draw. It is not a heavy or oily wrapper, which is why the cigar remains medium-bodied rather than full.
Where is Excalibur by Hoyo de Monterrey No. I made?
It is hand-rolled at the General Cigar facility in Danlí, Honduras. That factory, often associated with the Villazon brand, is known for consistent construction and has been producing Honduran cigars for decades. The Excalibur line has been made there since its introduction in the 1970s, and the factory's expertise is evident in the even burn and firm ash of every No. I.