Overview

There is a particular kind of confidence in a cigar that knows exactly what it is. The Montecristo Open Eagle does not reach for the impossible heights of its Cuban namesakes, nor does it pretend to be a limited-edition unicorn. Instead, it plants its flag firmly in the territory of the well-made, the approachable, and the reliably enjoyable. Launched in 2009 as the flagship of the Open series, the Eagle is Montecristo's invitation to a broader audience — a large-format figurado designed to deliver the brand's signature elegance without the intimidation factor or the premium price tag. It is, in essence, a democratization play, and it executes that mission with a quiet competence that deserves attention.

The pre-light ritual sets the tone. A cold draw reveals sweet hay, toasted almond, and a whisper of light cream — a gentle handshake rather than a firm grip. Once lit, the first third unfurls with a smooth, almost pillowy creaminess that coats the palate. Mild cedar emerges, soft and pencil-shaving-like, layered with a delicate floral note that speaks directly to the Ecuadorian Connecticut Shade wrapper. There is no harshness here, no pepper bomb, no rush. The strength sits squarely in the mild-to-medium range, making it an easy companion for a morning coffee or an early afternoon respite.

As the burn progresses into the second third, the blend finds its footing and gains complexity. Dry roasted nuts — cashew and hazelnut — step forward, joined by a distinct white pepper that tickles the retrohale without overwhelming it. A gentle earthiness enters mid-stick, grounded and slightly sweet, balanced by continuing cedar and a touch of mild honey. The large 58-ring gauge proves its worth here, cooling the smoke and smoothing out the transitions between flavors. It is not a challenging cigar, but it is a rewarding one, offering a clear progression that rewards attention without demanding it.

The final third brings a modest uptick in body. Toasted bread crust and light espresso notes emerge, mingling with lingering wood and a pepper that persists at a manageable level. The finish is medium-length, clean, and slightly sweet with a cedar aftertaste that never turns harsh or bitter. Construction is generally reliable — the draw is open and effortless, the burn even, and the firm light-grey ash holds an inch or more, though occasional minor touch-ups are typical for this price tier. The Eagle is a 60-to-70-minute smoke, well-suited for afternoon sessions or casual social occasions. It won't challenge a seasoned palate, but it earns its place as a gateway into Dominican craftsmanship — a reliable, well-branded cigar that punches above its price point.

Cigar Specifications

WrapperEcuadorian Connecticut Shade — Colorado Claro
BinderDominican Olor
FillerDominican Republic — a blend of Dominican long-fillers including Piloto Cubano and Olor ligero
Country of OriginSantiago, Dominican Republic — General Cigar / La Romana facilities
Vitola / ShapeEagle (Torpedo/Figurado)
Size6.0 x 58
StrengthMedium
Price$12–$16 per cigar
TierEveryday
AgingMinimal declared aging; tobaccos blended for accessible, consistent expression rather than extended cellaring

Tasting Notes & Flavor Progression

First Third

The cold draw opens with sweet hay, toasted almond, and light cream. Once lit, the first third delivers smooth creaminess layered with mild cedar and a soft floral note from the Ecuadorian wrapper. Strength is decidedly mild-to-medium with no harshness.

Second Third

The blend gains complexity as dry roasted nuts — cashew and hazelnut — emerge alongside white pepper on the retrohale. A gentle earthiness enters mid-stick, balanced by continuing cedar and a touch of mild honey sweetness. The large ring gauge cools the smoke and smooths out transitions.

Final Third

The final third brings a modest uptick in body with toasted bread crust, light espresso, and lingering wood notes. The pepper persists at a manageable level. Finish is medium-length with a clean, slightly sweet cedar aftertaste — it never turns harsh or bitter.

Construction, Burn & Draw

Construction is generally reliable — the draw is open and effortless given the wide 58-ring figurado format. Burn tends to be even with a firm, light-grey ash holding an inch or more; occasional minor touch-ups may be needed, typical for the accessible price tier.

Pairing Recommendations

Spirit

Aged Dominican rum such as Barceló Imperial or a light Tennessee whiskey like George Dickel No. 12 — the cigar's creaminess pairs well with soft vanilla-forward spirits

Wine

A lightly oaked Chardonnay or a Viognier — the creamy, nutty profile mirrors the cigar's texture; alternatively a mild Pinot Noir from Burgundy

Non-Alcoholic

A medium-roast Colombian coffee with a light cream — amplifies the almond and cedar notes without overwhelming the cigar's subtlety

Who Should Smoke This?

Picture a Thursday afternoon in late spring. You've wrapped up your last call, the laptop is closed, and the porch is bathed in that soft, golden light that makes everything look forgiving. You're not a beginner, but you're not a collector with a humidor full of aged Cubans either. You enjoy a good Connecticut-wrapped cigar with your morning coffee, and you've been curious about figurados but haven't wanted to commit to a $30 stick just to try the shape. The Open Eagle is for you. It's approachable enough that you won't be punished for smoking it too fast, yet refined enough that you'll notice the cashew and honey notes if you slow down. It's the cigar you hand to a friend who wants to learn, and the one you reach for yourself when you want a reliable, satisfying smoke without the ceremony.

Bottom Line

The Montecristo Open Eagle is not trying to be the best cigar you'll ever smoke — it's trying to be the one you'll actually smoke. It succeeds. A creamy, nutty, cedar-laced figurado that delivers consistent pleasure at a price that invites repetition.

Similar Cigars

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Montecristo Open Eagle a strong cigar?

No. It is rated Medium (3/5) in strength. Physically, this means you'll feel a gentle warmth and a slight nicotine tingle but no head rush or heavy body load. It's suitable for smokers who prefer milder cigars or for those who want a substantial smoke without the intensity of a full-bodied blend.

What does Montecristo Open Eagle taste like?

The flavor progresses in three distinct phases. The first third offers sweet hay, toasted almond, light cream, mild cedar, and a soft floral note. The second third introduces dry roasted cashew and hazelnut, white pepper on the retrohale, gentle earthiness, and a touch of honey. The final third brings toasted bread crust, light espresso, lingering wood, and a persistent but manageable pepper, finishing with a clean, slightly sweet cedar aftertaste.

How long does Montecristo Open Eagle take to smoke?

Given its 6.0 x 58 figurado format, expect a smoking time of approximately 60 to 70 minutes. The large ring gauge slows the burn and keeps the smoke cool, so rushing it will diminish the experience. Set aside at least an hour to enjoy it properly.

What is the best pairing for Montecristo Open Eagle?

An aged Dominican rum such as Barceló Imperial is the ideal spirit pairing — its soft vanilla and caramel notes mirror the cigar's creaminess and nutty profile. For wine, a lightly oaked Chardonnay or a Viognier works beautifully, as the creamy texture of the wine echoes the cigar's mouthfeel. If you prefer non-alcoholic, a medium-roast Colombian coffee with a touch of light cream amplifies the almond and cedar notes without overwhelming the cigar's subtlety.

Is Montecristo Open Eagle good for beginners?

Yes, it is an excellent choice for beginners. Its Medium strength is gentle enough to avoid nicotine sickness, and its flavor profile is smooth and approachable without harshness. At $12–$16 per cigar, it is also affordable enough to experiment with. The large ring gauge makes it easy to draw, though new smokers should puff slowly to keep the burn cool.

Where can I buy Montecristo Open Eagle?

Montecristo Open Eagle is sold at premium cigar retailers, both brick-and-mortar tobacconists and reputable online cigar shops. Look for authorized Montecristo dealers to ensure authenticity. It is typically available in boxes of 20, though many retailers sell singles or five-packs for those who want to try before committing to a full box.

What is the price of Montecristo Open Eagle?

The Montecristo Open Eagle is priced between $12 and $16 per cigar. This places it in the everyday tier — affordable enough for regular rotation but still offering the construction and branding of a premium Dominican cigar.

Is Montecristo Open Eagle worth aging?

No, it is not designed for extended aging. The tobaccos are blended for accessible, consistent expression rather than long-term cellaring, and the Ecuadorian Connecticut Shade wrapper is delicate. While a few months of rest can mellow it slightly, the cigar is intended to be smoked fresh. Aging it for years will likely diminish its creamy, nutty character rather than improve it.

What wrapper does Montecristo Open Eagle use?

It uses an Ecuadorian Connecticut Shade wrapper. This wrapper is known for its silky texture, warm golden-tan color (Colorado Claro), and subtle sheen. It contributes the cigar's creamy smoothness, mild cedar notes, and soft floral undertones, while keeping the overall strength in the medium range.

Where is Montecristo Open Eagle made?

It is made in Santiago, Dominican Republic, at General Cigar's La Romana facilities. The cigar is machine-bunched and hand-finished, a production method that helps maintain consistency and affordability while still delivering reliable construction.