Overview

There is a moment, somewhere in the second third of the My Father No. 2 Toro, when the cigar stops being a cigar and becomes an argument. The argument is this: that a $14–$18 stick from a core lineup can outclass prestige smokes at twice the price, and that Pepín and Jaime García have been making that argument — quietly, relentlessly — since this line debuted in the early 2010s. The No. 2 Toro is not the flashiest cigar in the My Father portfolio. It doesn't need to be. It is the one that shows up every time, the one that seasoned smokers reach for when they want to remember why they fell in love with Nicaraguan tobacco in the first place.\n\nBefore the flame even touches the foot, the wrapper tells you something. That Colorado shade — rich reddish-brown, silky, with just a whisper of natural oil — promises depth without heaviness. The cold draw offers dry cocoa and a faint cedar shaving, a quiet overture to what follows. Then the first third arrives with confidence: roasted espresso, toasted cedar, and a red pepper spice that announces itself on the retrohale like a knock at the door. Dark chocolate and dry cocoa powder build the foundation, and as the cigar settles, a dried fig sweetness emerges — not candy, not syrup, but the concentrated sugar of fruit left in the sun.\n\nThe middle third is where the No. 2 Toro earns its reputation. The pepper doesn't vanish; it integrates, softening into the background while aged leather and sun-dried tobacco take the lead. A creamy nougat sweetness threads through the smoke, and beneath it, roasted cashew and almond surface alongside a mineral earthiness that tastes like the Jalapa valley itself — cool, dark, and ancient. This is the section you'll want to slow down for. Complexity and balance reach their peak here, and the temptation to rush is the only mistake this cigar allows you to make.\n\nThe final third intensifies without turning harsh. Roasted espresso returns with greater depth, joined by dark cocoa, charred oak, and a long black pepper finish that lingers on the palate like a closing argument. The sweetness recedes. A bold, savory earthiness dominates. Strength upticks noticeably — this is a medium-full cigar that finishes closer to full — but it remains controlled, delivering a satisfying, full-bodied conclusion that never tips into brutality. The burn line stays razor-sharp throughout, the draw offers just the right resistance, and the ash holds dense and silver-grey well past the one-inch mark. Ninety minutes to two hours later, you'll understand why this cigar has outlasted trends, hype cycles, and the endless parade of limited editions. It is the workhorse of the My Father core lineup, and it embarrasses many 'prestige' sticks at twice the cost.

Cigar Specifications

WrapperNicaraguan Corojo — Colorado
BinderNicaraguan Jalapa
FillerNicaraguan long-filler blend from Jalapa and Estelí, aged a minimum of 3 years
Country of OriginEstelí, Nicaragua — My Father Cigars S.A. factory
Vitola / ShapeToro
Size6 x 52
StrengthMedium-Full
Price$14–$18 per cigar
TierPremium
AgingTobaccos aged a minimum of three years prior to rolling; additional box aging recommended at 65% RH for 1–3 months post-

Tasting Notes & Flavor Progression

First Third

The first third opens with a confident burst of roasted espresso, toasted cedar, and a distinctive red pepper spice on the retrohale. Underlying notes of dark chocolate and dry cocoa powder establish a rich, full aromatic foundation. Sweetness hints of dried fruit — specifically dried fig or raisin — emerge as the cigar settles into its draw.

Second Third

The middle third is where this cigar earns its reputation — the pepper integrates and softens, giving way to aged leather, sun-dried tobacco, and a creamy nougat sweetness. A secondary layer of roasted nuts, specifically cashew and almond, surfaces alongside a mineral earthiness reminiscent of Nicaraguan Jalapa terroir. Complexity and balance are at their peak.

Final Third

The final third intensifies without turning harsh — roasted espresso returns with greater depth, complemented by dark cocoa, charred oak, and a long, lingering black pepper finish. The sweetness recedes and a bold, savory earthiness dominates. The strength upticks noticeably but remains controlled, delivering a satisfying, full-bodied conclusion.

Construction, Burn & Draw

Construction is exemplary — the Garcías factory delivers consistent, near-flawless draw with just the right resistance, and the burn line stays razor-sharp with minimal touch-ups required. Ash is dense, tight, and silver-grey, typically holding past the one-inch mark with ease.

Pairing Recommendations

Spirit

Aged Nicaraguan rum (e.g., Flor de Caña 18 Year) or a wheated bourbon such as Maker's Mark 46 — both complement the chocolate and spice notes without overwhelming the cigar's nuance

Wine

A full-bodied Malbec from Mendoza (e.g., Catena Zapata Adrianna Vineyard) or a Monastrell from Jumilla — the dark fruit and earth tones mirror the cigar's core flavor profile

Non-Alcoholic

A double espresso or a dark roast cold brew — the coffee mirror effect with this cigar is nearly seamless; alternatively, a strong Assam black tea with no milk

Who Should Smoke This?

Picture a seasoned medium-bodied smoker — someone who has spent a few years with Connecticuts and Habano wrappers, who appreciates complexity but isn't ready to commit to a full-bodied Nicaraguan powerhouse. It's a Saturday afternoon in late autumn, the kind of day that invites a two-hour session on the porch with nowhere to be. They pour a glass of aged rum, settle into a chair, and light the No. 2 Toro. What they get is a bridge: the elegance and balance of a refined blend, paired with the depth and spice that Nicaraguan tobacco is famous for. It's substantial enough to feel like an occasion, accessible enough to become a ritual. This is the cigar that will teach them what Estelí terroir actually tastes like — and they'll remember the lesson.

Bottom Line

The My Father No. 2 Toro is the rare cigar that delivers prestige-level complexity at a working-smoker's price. It is the definitive bridge between medium and full-bodied Nicaraguan blends, and it belongs in every serious humidor. Buy a box, smoke one now, and age the rest — you'll thank yourself either way.

Similar Cigars

Frequently Asked Questions

Is My Father No. 2 Toro a strong cigar?

It is rated Medium-Full (4/5), which means it sits firmly in the upper-middle range. Physically, you'll feel a noticeable uptick in strength during the final third — a warming sensation in the chest and a slight nicotine buzz — but it never becomes overwhelming or harsh. If you regularly smoke medium-bodied cigars, you'll handle it comfortably. If you're new to Nicaraguan tobacco, eat a full meal first and keep a sweet drink nearby.

What does My Father No. 2 Toro taste like?

The first third delivers roasted espresso, toasted cedar, red pepper on the retrohale, dark chocolate, dry cocoa powder, and dried fig sweetness. The second third transitions to aged leather, sun-dried tobacco, creamy nougat, roasted cashew, almond, and a mineral earthiness. The final third brings back roasted espresso with greater depth, dark cocoa, charred oak, and a long black pepper finish with savory earthiness.

How long does My Father No. 2 Toro take to smoke?

As a 6 x 52 Toro, expect a 90-minute to 2-hour smoke depending on your pace. Slower smokers who take a draw every minute or so will push toward the two-hour mark; faster smokers may finish closer to 90 minutes. The excellent construction means it burns evenly and doesn't require rushing.

What is the best pairing for My Father No. 2 Toro?

An aged Nicaraguan rum such as Flor de Caña 18 Year is the ideal spirit pairing — its caramel and oak notes complement the cigar's chocolate and spice without overwhelming the nuance. For wine, a full-bodied Malbec from Mendoza (Catena Zapata Adrianna Vineyard) mirrors the dark fruit and earth tones. Non-alcoholic? A double espresso creates a nearly seamless coffee mirror effect.

Is My Father No. 2 Toro good for beginners?

Honestly, no — not for absolute beginners. At Medium-Full strength with a $14–$18 price tag, it's better suited to smokers who have already developed their palate on milder cigars. A beginner might find the final third too intense and the price too steep for a learning experience. Start with a Connecticut-wrapped cigar, then graduate to this one after a year or so of regular smoking.

Where can I buy My Father No. 2 Toro?

This is a premium, hand-rolled cigar sold at authorized tobacconists, specialty cigar shops, and reputable online retailers that carry the My Father brand. You won't find it at gas stations or convenience stores. Look for brick-and-mortar shops with proper humidification, or established online vendors like Cigars International, Famous Smoke Shop, or JR Cigar. Always verify the retailer is an authorized dealer to avoid counterfeits.

What is the price of My Father No. 2 Toro?

Expect to pay between $14 and $18 per cigar, depending on your state's tobacco taxes and the retailer's markup. A box of 20 typically runs $280–$360. At this price point, it consistently punches above its weight class and outperforms many cigars costing $25 or more.

Is My Father No. 2 Toro worth aging?

Yes, though it's already aged before you buy it — the tobaccos in this blend are aged a minimum of three years prior to rolling. Additional box aging at 65% relative humidity for 1–3 months post-purchase will let the Nicaraguan Corojo wrapper settle and marry with the Jalapa and Estelí fillers, softening the pepper slightly and deepening the cocoa and dried fruit notes. Longer aging (6–12 months) can further round the edges, but this cigar is designed to smoke beautifully fresh.

What wrapper does My Father No. 2 Toro use?

It uses a Nicaraguan Corojo wrapper in a Colorado shade — rich reddish-brown, silky, with a light natural oil sheen. This wrapper contributes much of the cigar's red pepper spice, cedar, and earthy mineral character, while also providing the structural integrity that helps the burn line stay razor-sharp.

Where is My Father No. 2 Toro made?

It is hand-rolled at the My Father Cigars S.A. factory in Estelí, Nicaragua — the same facility where Pepín and Jaime García oversee production of the entire My Father core lineup. The No. 2 line was released circa 2011–2012 as one of the earlier extensions of the flagship My Father brand, and it remains a cornerstone of their portfolio.