Overview
There is a particular romance to a cigar rolled on American soil, and The American by J.C. Newman Natural Toro carries that romance not as a gimmick but as a birthright. Rolled at the historic El Reloj factory in Tampa—one of the last hand-rolling operations still standing in the United States—this Toro is a living artifact, a 6 x 50 salute to a time when cigar City was the beating heart of the industry. But sentiment alone does not earn a 90+ score. What earns it is the way this cigar performs: with a quiet, unpretentious confidence that never begs for attention yet rewards every moment you give it.
The pre-light aroma offers a gentle preview—toasted bread crust, a whisper of cedar shavings, and a faint sweetness like raw honeycomb. The cold draw is effortless, delivering mild nuttiness and a touch of dried hay. Upon lighting, the first third opens with a soft, creamy texture that coats the palate. Toasted bread and mild cedar take the lead, supported by a creamy nuttiness that feels like roasted almonds. A restrained sweetness—more suggestion than statement—keeps things balanced. On the retrohale, a subtle floral note appears alongside light white pepper, adding lift without bite. Smoke production is generous from the first puff, and the draw is inviting, never tight.
The second third deepens the narrative. Roasted nuts return, now darker and more pronounced, while a light leather note and mild earthiness add savory depth. Dried fruit emerges—golden raisin, specifically—and a gentle honey sweetness weaves through the profile, complementing the natural wrapper's character. Strength remains firmly medium, but the body builds in richness. This is where the cigar hits its stride, demonstrating that complexity need not shout to be heard. The burn line stays even, the ash holds firm in dense, light grey columns past an inch, and the draw remains effortless with ideal resistance.
The final third introduces a mild espresso bitterness and a touch of dark chocolate, deepening the profile without aggression. A warm woody spice on the finish rounds things out, leaving a clean, satisfying fade. Never once does it turn harsh or hot. The cigar maintains its composure to the nub, a testament to the skill of the Tampa rollers who crafted it. At $12–$16 per cigar, it sits comfortably in the premium tier, and it earns that placement through consistency and craftsmanship rather than sheer power or complexity. It is a 60–75 minute smoke ideal for an afternoon break or a relaxed post-dinner setting—approachable enough for a weekday ritual yet refined enough to deserve your full attention. This is not a cigar that will blow you away with bombast. It is a cigar that will win you over with grace, provenance, and the quiet assurance of a job done right.
Cigar Specifications
| Wrapper | Connecticut Broadleaf Natural — USA — Colorado |
|---|---|
| Binder | Nicaraguan |
| Filler | Nicaraguan and Honduran long-leaf tobaccos |
| Country of Origin | Tampa, Florida, USA — J.C. Newman's El Reloj factory |
| Vitola / Shape | Toro |
| Size | 6 x 50 |
| Strength | Medium |
| Price | $12–$16 per cigar |
| Tier | Premium |
| Aging | Tobaccos aged prior to rolling; no extended post-production aging noted |
Tasting Notes & Flavor Progression
First Third
The opening delivers toasted bread, mild cedar, and a creamy nuttiness with restrained sweetness. There is a subtle floral note on the retrohale alongside light white pepper. The draw is inviting and the smoke production generous from the first light.
Second Third
The body develops into a richer combination of roasted nuts, light leather, and a mild earthiness. Dried fruit undertones — think golden raisin — emerge alongside a gentle honey sweetness that complements the natural wrapper's character. Strength remains firmly medium.
Final Third
The final third introduces a mild espresso bitterness and a touch of dark chocolate that deepens the profile without aggression. A warm woody spice on the finish rounds things out. The cigar maintains its composure and never turns harsh, finishing with a clean, satisfying fade.
Construction, Burn & Draw
Construction is consistently excellent — a hallmark of J.C. Newman's skilled Tampa rollers. The burn line is even, the draw effortless with ideal resistance, and the ash holds firm in dense, light grey columns past an inch.
Pairing Recommendations
Spirit
A wheated bourbon such as Maker's Mark or W.L. Weller Special Reserve — the sweetness and vanilla character harmonize beautifully with the wrapper's natural sugars.
Wine
A medium-bodied Garnacha from Priorat or a domestic Pinot Noir from the Willamette Valley — both complement without overwhelming the cigar's measured complexity.
Non-Alcoholic
A lightly roasted single-origin Colombian drip coffee — medium roast, bright acidity — mirrors the toasted nut and cedar notes elegantly.
Who Should Smoke This?
Picture a seasoned aficionado on a quiet Saturday afternoon, the kind who has smoked through boxes of Nicaraguan powerhouses and Cuban classics, who appreciates a cigar that doesn't need to prove anything. He's sitting on a porch with a glass of wheated bourbon, no agenda, just an hour to himself. He's smoked plenty of high-octane blends and now wants something that rewards attention without demanding it. The American Natural Toro gives him that: a medium-bodied, flavorful smoke with a clear sense of place. It's for the smoker who reads the band, who knows what El Reloj means, and who finds satisfaction in a cigar that tastes like where it was made. It's also for the curious newcomer who wants to understand American cigar heritage without being overwhelmed by strength. This is a cigar for the thoughtful smoker, not the thrill-seeker.
Bottom Line
The American by J.C. Newman Natural Toro is a masterclass in balance and craftsmanship, delivering a medium-bodied, flavorful experience that never overpowers. It earns its premium price through consistency, provenance, and a sensory arc that satisfies from first light to final inch. If you value authenticity and a smoke that respects your time, this is a must-have for your humidor.
Similar Cigars
Explore all The American cigars.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is The American by J.C. Newman Natural Toro a strong cigar?
No, it is a medium-strength cigar (3/5). Physically, that means you'll feel a gentle nicotine presence—enough to satisfy but not enough to cause dizziness or require a full stomach. It's a cigar you can enjoy in the afternoon without feeling overwhelmed.
What does The American by J.C. Newman Natural Toro taste like?
The first third delivers toasted bread, mild cedar, creamy nuttiness, a subtle floral note on the retrohale, and light white pepper. The second third adds roasted nuts, light leather, mild earthiness, golden raisin, and honey sweetness. The final third introduces mild espresso bitterness, dark chocolate, and a warm woody spice on the finish.
How long does The American by J.C. Newman Natural Toro take to smoke?
Given its Toro vitola (6 x 50), expect a 60–75 minute smoking time, depending on your pace and how often you puff. It's an ideal length for an afternoon break or a relaxed post-dinner session.
What is the best pairing for The American by J.C. Newman Natural Toro?
A wheated bourbon such as Maker's Mark or W.L. Weller Special Reserve is an excellent choice—the sweetness and vanilla character harmonize beautifully with the wrapper's natural sugars. For wine, a medium-bodied Garnacha from Priorat or a Willamette Valley Pinot Noir complements without overwhelming. For a non-alcoholic option, a lightly roasted single-origin Colombian drip coffee mirrors the toasted nut and cedar notes elegantly.
Is The American by J.C. Newman Natural Toro good for beginners?
Yes, it is an excellent choice for beginners due to its medium strength and approachable flavor profile. However, at $12–$16 per cigar, it's a bit pricey for a novice who might not yet appreciate its nuances. If you're new to cigars but willing to invest in quality, this is a great introduction to American craftsmanship.
Where can I buy The American by J.C. Newman Natural Toro?
This cigar is sold at premium tobacconists, online cigar retailers, and directly through J.C. Newman's website. Look for authorized dealers to ensure authenticity and proper storage. It comes in boxes of 20.
What is the price of The American by J.C. Newman Natural Toro?
The American by J.C. Newman Natural Toro is priced between $12 and $16 per cigar, placing it in the premium tier. Boxes of 20 are available at a corresponding price.
Is The American by J.C. Newman Natural Toro worth aging?
While the tobaccos are aged prior to rolling, there is no extended post-production aging noted. The Connecticut Broadleaf Natural wrapper and Nicaraguan/Honduran fillers are already well-balanced, so additional aging may soften the profile slightly but is not necessary. If you choose to age, try 6–12 months to see how the flavors meld.
What wrapper does The American by J.C. Newman Natural Toro use?
It uses a Connecticut Broadleaf Natural — USA wrapper with a Colorado shade and Colorado color (medium brown, smooth with a subtle earthy sheen). This wrapper contributes a natural sweetness, earthy undertones, and a smooth texture that complements the Nicaraguan binder and Nicaraguan/Honduran fillers.
Where is The American by J.C. Newman Natural Toro made?
It is hand-rolled at J.C. Newman's historic El Reloj cigar factory in Tampa, Florida, USA—one of the last remaining hand-rolling operations in the United States. The American line was launched to celebrate American cigar heritage and the factory's legacy.