Overview
The American by J.C. Newman Toro opens with a pre-light aroma that promises something different: dark fruit compote, fresh-turned earth, and a faint molasses sweetness rising from the Pennsylvania Broadleaf wrapper. The cold draw delivers dried cherry, cocoa nib, and a whisper of black pepper. Lighting it, the first third announces itself with bold dark cocoa and roasted espresso, but the real signature is the dried fruit—plum and dark cherry—riding a prominent earthiness. That barnyard sweetness is unmistakably Pennsylvania Broadleaf, and it separates this cigar from any Nicaraguan maduro on the market. The retrohale carries a soft baking spice that keeps the opening from becoming monolithic.
As the burn progresses into the second third, the cigar finds its stride. Leather and toasted oak take the lead, with black pepper picking up tempo on the retrohale. A caramel undertone emerges, balancing the medium-full strength and adding a layer of richness that keeps the smoke from tipping into harshness. The Nicaraguan and Honduran long-fillers provide a sturdy backbone, but they never overshadow the wrapper's distinctive character. This is where the blend becomes genuinely layered—complex without becoming chaotic, each puff revealing a new facet of the same story.
The final third intensifies with dark roast coffee, charred cedar, and a lingering molasses sweetness. Black pepper remains present but doesn't overpower; instead, it frames a long, earthy finish with a mineral note on the aftertaste that invites another draw. The burn line stays even throughout, producing thick, creamy smoke and a firm, charcoal-gray ash that holds well past the inch mark. The draw is typically slightly firm to perfect—never tight, never loose—a testament to the hand-rolling at El Reloj.
What makes The American genuinely important beyond marketing is that it proves American tobacco, particularly Pennsylvania Broadleaf, can anchor a world-class blend. J.C. Newman deserves credit for keeping domestic cigar manufacturing alive in Tampa; smoking this is both a quality experience and a historical act. It's a cigar for the aficionado who wants Nicaraguan complexity with an unmistakably American character—a 90–100 minute journey best enjoyed in the evening when you have space to appreciate its evolution, or as a weekend afternoon smoke for those who prefer full-flavored intensity over delicate nuance.
Cigar Specifications
| Wrapper | Pennsylvania Broadleaf Maduro — Maduro |
|---|---|
| Binder | Nicaraguan |
| Filler | Nicaraguan and Honduran long-filler tobaccos |
| Country of Origin | Tampa, Florida, USA — J.C. Newman's El Reloj Factory |
| Vitola / Shape | Toro |
| Size | 6 x 50 |
| Strength | Medium-Full |
| Price | $12–$16 per cigar |
| Tier | Premium |
| Aging | Tobaccos undergo extended fermentation; Pennsylvania Broadleaf receives traditional air-curing and aging |
Tasting Notes & Flavor Progression
First Third
The first third opens with a bold declaration of dark cocoa, roasted espresso, and dried fruit — plum and dark cherry notes riding underneath a prominent earthiness. The Pennsylvania Broadleaf delivers a distinctive barnyard sweetness that separates this from any Nicaraguan maduro on the market.
Second Third
The mid-section transitions into leather and toasted oak, with black pepper picking up tempo on the retrohale. A caramel undertone emerges, balancing the strength as the cigar reaches its stride — complex and layered without becoming chaotic.
Final Third
The final third intensifies with dark roast coffee, charred cedar, and a lingering molasses sweetness. Black pepper remains present but doesn't overpower; the finish is long, earthy, and satisfying with a mineral note on the aftertaste.
Construction, Burn & Draw
Construction at El Reloj is reliably solid — the draw is typically slightly firm to perfect, producing thick, creamy smoke. The burn line is even with a firm, charcoal-gray ash that holds well past the inch mark.
Pairing Recommendations
Spirit
Bourbon with high corn content — Buffalo Trace or Maker's Mark 46 complement the dark fruit and caramel notes beautifully; alternatively a dark rum like Zacapa 23
Wine
A fruit-forward California Zinfandel or a Malbec from Mendoza — both have the dark fruit density to match the Broadleaf's intensity
Non-Alcoholic
A cold-brew coffee with chicory, or a dark roast single-origin Ethiopian — mirrors the cocoa and dried fruit interplay in the smoke
Who Should Smoke This?
This is for the seasoned aficionado who has spent years exploring Nicaraguan and Dominican blends and is ready for something that tastes like where it was made. Picture a Saturday evening in late autumn, the grill has just cooled, and you have an hour and a half before the embers die. You pour two fingers of high-corn bourbon—Buffalo Trace or Maker's Mark 46—and settle into a chair that faces west. You already love full-bodied maduros but you're tired of the same earthy-spicy script. The American gives you that familiar backbone but wraps it in dried fruit, molasses, and a barnyard sweetness you can't find anywhere else. It's not a beginner's cigar; the medium-full strength and $12–$16 price point assume you know what you're doing and you're willing to pay for something with a story. Smoke it slowly. Let the final third's mineral note linger.
Bottom Line
The American by J.C. Newman Toro is a landmark smoke that proves Pennsylvania Broadleaf can stand shoulder-to-shoulder with the world's best wrappers. It delivers a full-flavored, medium-full experience that evolves from dark fruit and cocoa to leather, caramel, and charred cedar without ever losing its balance. Buy a box, smoke one now, and age the rest—this is American cigar history you can taste.
Similar Cigars
Explore all The American cigars.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is The American by J.C. Newman Toro a strong cigar?
Yes, it is rated Medium-Full (4/5). Physically, that means you will feel a noticeable nicotine presence, especially if you smoke it on an empty stomach. The strength builds gradually from the first third to the final third, but it never becomes overwhelming. Most experienced smokers will find it robust yet manageable; newcomers should eat a full meal beforehand and sip a sugary drink if they feel lightheaded.
What does The American by J.C. Newman Toro taste like?
The first third delivers bold dark cocoa, roasted espresso, and dried fruit—plum and dark cherry—over a prominent earthiness with a distinctive barnyard sweetness. The second third transitions to leather and toasted oak, with black pepper on the retrohale and a caramel undertone. The final third intensifies with dark roast coffee, charred cedar, and lingering molasses sweetness, finishing with a mineral note on the aftertaste.
How long does The American by J.C. Newman Toro take to smoke?
As a 6 x 50 Toro, this cigar typically takes 90 to 100 minutes to smoke at a moderate pace. If you puff quickly, it may finish in 75–85 minutes, but you will miss the nuanced transitions between thirds. For the full experience—especially the caramel in the second third and the mineral finish—set aside a full hour and a half.
What is the best pairing for The American by J.C. Newman Toro?
A high-corn bourbon like Buffalo Trace or Maker's Mark 46 is ideal because its sweetness complements the dark fruit and caramel notes in the cigar. Alternatively, a dark rum like Zacapa 23 enhances the molasses and cocoa. For wine, choose a fruit-forward California Zinfandel or a Mendoza Malbec—both have the dark fruit density to match the Broadleaf's intensity. Non-alcoholic options include cold-brew coffee with chicory or a dark roast Ethiopian single-origin.
Is The American by J.C. Newman Toro good for beginners?
Not really. At Medium-Full strength and $12–$16 per cigar, it is best suited for smokers who already enjoy full-bodied maduros and can handle a nicotine kick. Beginners may find the strength overwhelming and the price point risky for an experimental smoke. If you are new to cigars, start with a milder Connecticut Shade or a medium-bodied Habano before graduating to this one.
Where can I buy The American by J.C. Newman Toro?
This cigar is sold at premium tobacconists, upscale cigar lounges, and online retailers that specialize in boutique and heritage brands. Look for authorized J.C. Newman dealers, as the brand is distributed selectively. You can also check the J.C. Newman website for a store locator or purchase directly from their online shop if available.
What is the price of The American by J.C. Newman Toro?
The American by J.C. Newman Toro typically retails for $12–$16 per cigar, depending on the retailer and local taxes. A box of 20 will generally cost between $240 and $320. Given the hand-rolled construction in Tampa and the extended fermentation of the tobaccos, this is a fair price for a premium, historically significant smoke.
Is The American by J.C. Newman Toro worth aging?
Yes, it is worth aging. The tobaccos already undergo extended fermentation, and the Pennsylvania Broadleaf wrapper receives traditional air-curing and aging, so the cigar is ready to smoke now. However, another 6–12 months in a humidor at 65–68% RH will mellow the black pepper slightly and deepen the dried fruit and caramel notes. Beyond two years, the wrapper's oils may dull, so aim for one to two years of rest for optimal results.
What wrapper does The American by J.C. Newman Toro use?
It uses a Pennsylvania Broadleaf Maduro wrapper. This wrapper is grown in Pennsylvania, air-cured, and aged to develop its deep espresso-brown color and natural tooth. It contributes the cigar's distinctive barnyard sweetness, dark cocoa, and dried fruit notes, setting it apart from Nicaraguan or Ecuadorian maduros.
Where is The American by J.C. Newman Toro made?
It is hand-rolled at J.C. Newman's historic El Reloj factory in Ybor City, Tampa, Florida, USA. El Reloj is one of the last operating cigar factories in the United States, and production there supports American tobacco heritage. The cigar was launched circa 2016 as a patriotic tribute to domestic tobacco.